Case ID: ICSID Case No. ARB/98/2Country: ChileSpainClaimant: Pey CasadoRespondent: ChileTreaty: Chile-Spain BITDocuments: Annex 1: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General 6 Apr 1999 Annex 1: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General Annex 2: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General 8 Apr 1999 Annex 2: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General Annex 4: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General 19 Apr 1999 Annex 4: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General Decision on Provisional Measures 25 Sep 2001 Decision on Provisional Measures (Spanish) Decision on Provisional Measures (French) Decision 8 May 2002 Decision (French) Opinion of Prof. Guillermo Bruna 27 Jun 2002 Opinion of Prof. Guillermo Bruna (French) Opinion of Prof. Guillermo Bruna (Spanish) Opinion of Alejandro Arraez and Associates 3 Sep 2002 Opinion of Alejandro Arraez and Associates (French) Opinion of Alejandro Arraez and Associates (Spanish) Opinion of Professor Fernando Mariño 19 Feb 2003 Opinion of Professor Fernando Mariño (French) Opinion of Professor Fernando Mariño (Spanish) Procedural Order No. 13 24 Oct 2006 Procedural Order No. 13 (French) Procedural Order No. 13 (Spanish) Procedural Order No. 14 22 Nov 2006 Procedural Order No. 14 (French) Procedural Order No. 14 (Spanish) Annex 1: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award 23 Mar 2007 Annex 1: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (French) Accompanying Document to: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award 23 Mar 2007 Accompanying Document to: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (French) Decision on Arbitration Expenses 14 Mar 2008 Decision on Arbitration Expenses (French) Decision on Arbitration Expenses (Spanish) Award 8 May 2008 Award (French) Award (Spanish) Annex 2: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award 26 May 2008 Annex 2: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (Spanish) Accompanying Document II to: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award 26 May 2008 Accompanying Document II to: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (French) Application for Revision 2 Jun 2008 Application for Revision (French) Application for Revision (Spanish) Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award 1 Aug 2008 Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (French) Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (Spanish) Decision on Stay of Enforcement of the Award 5 Aug 2008 Decision on Stay of Enforcement of the Award (French) Decision on Stay of Enforcement of the Award (Spanish) Annex 3: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General 10 Sep 2008 Annex 3: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General Claimants' Reply, Application for Revision 3 Nov 2008 Claimants' Reply, Application for Revision (French) Claimants' Reply, Application for Revision (Spanish) Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General 10 Jul 2009 Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General (French) Decision 18 Nov 2009 Decision (on Revision) (French) Decision (on Revision) (Spanish) Minutes of the First Session of the ad hoc Committee 29 Jan 2010 Minutes of the First Session of the ad hoc Committee (French) Decision on Admissibility of the Application for Annulment 4 May 2010 Decision on Admissibility of the Application for Annulment (French) Decision on the Republic of Chile's Application for a Stay of Enforcement of the Award 5 May 2010 Decision on the Republic of Chile's Application for a Stay of Enforcement of the Award Claimants' Response to the Application for Annulment of the Award 15 Oct 2010 Claimants' Response to the Application for Annulment of the Award (French) Claimants' Response to the Application for Annulment of the Award (Spanish) Rejoinder to Response to Chile's Annulment Application 28 Feb 2011 Rejoinder to Response to Chile's Annulment Application (French) Rejoinder to Response to Chile's Annulment Application (Spanish) Annulment Proceeding Transcript 7 Jun 2011 Annulment Proceeding Transcript (French) Annulment Proceeding Transcript 8 Jun 2011 Annulment Proceeding Transcript (French) Decision on the Application for Annulment of the Republic of Chile 18 Dec 2012 Decision on the Application for Annulment of the Republic of Chile (French) Decision on the Application for Annulment of the Republic of Chile (English) Decree of Spanish Court of First Instance 6 Mar 2013 Decree of Spanish Court of First Instance (Spanish) Resolution of Spanish Court of First Instance 6 Mar 2013 Resolution of Spanish Court of First Instance (Spanish) Response to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision 29 Mar 2013 Response to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision (French) Response to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision 29 Mar 2013 Response to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision (Spanish) Response to Chile's Request for Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award of 8 May 2008 8 Apr 2013 Response to Chile's Request for Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award of 8 May 2008 (French) Reply to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision 26 Apr 2013 Reply to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision (Spanish) Reply to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision (French) Decision on Chile's Request for a Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award 16 May 2013 Decision on Chile's Request for a Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award (English) Decision on Chile's Request for a Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award (Spanish) Decision on Chile's Request for a Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award (French) Requête en vue de déterminer le montant de la réparation pour violation de l'API Espagne-Chili 18 Jun 2013 Requête en vue de déterminer le montant de la réparation pour violation de l'API Espagne-Chili (French) Decision of Spanish Court on Execution of Award 4 Jul 2013 Decision of Spanish Court on Execution of Award (Spanish) Annex 2 to Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal 10 Jul 2013 Annex 2 to Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal (French) Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal 10 Jul 2013 Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal (French) Annex 1 to Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal 10 Jul 2013 Annex 1 to Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal (French) Letter from the Claimant, Aug 23 2013 23 Aug 2013 Letter from the Claimant, Aug 23 2013 (French) Decision on the Republic of Chile's Request for Supplementation of the Annulment Decision 11 Sep 2013 Decision on the Republic of Chile's Request for Supplementation of the Annulment Decision (English) Decision on the Republic of Chile's Request for Supplementation of the Annulment Decision (French) Decision on the Republic of Chile's Request for Supplementation of the Annulment Decision (Spanish) Letter of Philippe Sands to ICSID on his appointment to the Tribunal 11 Sep 2013 Letter of Philippe Sands to ICSID on his appointment to the Tribunal Claimant's Submissions on Constitution of Arbitral Tribunal 26 Dec 2013 Claimant's Submissions on Constitution of Arbitral Tribunal (French) Philippe Sands' Letter of Resignation from the Tribunal 10 Jan 2014 Philippe Sands' Letter of Resignation from the Tribunal Comments on the Proposed Disqualification of Philippe Sands 23 Jan 2014 Comments on the Proposed Disqualification of Philippe Sands (French) Claimants’ Memorial on Quantum 27 Jun 2014 Claimants’ Memorial on Quantum (French) Claimants’ Memorial on Quantum (Spanish) Overview of Chile’s Tactics that Have Frustrated the Arbitration 27 Jun 2014 Overview of Chile’s Tactics that Have Frustrated the Arbitration (French) Claimant's Reply 9 Jan 2015 Claimant's Reply (Spanish) Claimant's Reply (French) Request for Correction of Material Errors in the Award of 13 September 2016 27 Oct 2016 Request for Correction of Material Errors in the Award of 13 September 2016 (French) Claimants’ Request to Chile for Full Disclosure of Its Relationship with Members of the Essex Court Chamber 13 Oct 2016 Claimants’ Request to Chile for Full Disclosure of Its Relationship with Members of the Essex Court Chamber (French)Source: IA Reporter Claimants' Request for the Interpretation of the Award of 8 May 2008 7 Oct 2016 Claimants' Request for the Interpretation of the Award of 8 May 2008 (French) Request for the Annulment of the Award dated 8 May 2008 5 Sep 2008 Request for the Annulment of the Award dated 8 May 2008Source: ICSID Website Request for Disqualification of Professor Philippe Sands as Arbitrator in the Resubmission Proceeding 18 Dec 2013 Request for Disqualification of Professor Philippe Sands as Arbitrator in the Resubmission ProceedingSource: ICSID Website Award 13 Sep 2016 Award (French) Award (Spanish) Award (English)Source: IA Reporter Recommendation of the PCA Secretary-General as to the Proposal for the Disqualification of Prof. Lalive and Judge bedjaoui 17 Feb 2006 Recommendation of the PCA Secretary-General as to the Proposal for the Disqualification of Prof. Lalive and Judge bedjaouiSource: ICSID Website Hearings of 13, 14, 15 and 16 April 2015 16 Apr 2015 Hearings of 13, 14, 15 and 16 April 2015Source: ICSID Website Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 5 Dec 2005 Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French)Source: ICSID Website The Secretary General of ICSID reveals the contents of the ex parte meeting of 02-09-2005 with the High Delegation of Chile 2 Dec 2005 The Secretary General of ICSID reveals the contents of the ex parte meeting of 02-09-2005 with the High Delegation of ChileSource: ICSID Website Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 28 Nov 2005 Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 17 Nov 2005 Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 7 Oct 2005 Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 4 Oct 2005 Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Ex parte Meeting of a High Delegation of Chile with the Secretary General of ICSID 8 Sep 2005 Ex parte Meeting of a High Delegation of Chile with the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Ex parte Meeting of a High Delegation of Chile with the Secretary General of ICSID (Spanish) Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 2 Sep 2005 Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Resignation of Mr Leoro Franco 26 Aug 2005 Resignation of Mr Leoro Franco (French) Respondent's Request for the Disqualification of the Three Members of the Tribunal 24 Aug 2005 Respondent's Request for the Disqualification of the Three Members of the Tribunal (Spanish) Claimants Ask the General Secretary of ICSID to Appoint a Qualified New Arbitrator 11 May 2006 Claimants Ask the General Secretary of ICSID to Appoint a Qualified New Arbitrator Response of the Secretary General of ICSID 7 Mar 2006 Response of the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Claimants' letter to the Chairman of the Administrative Council of ICSID 2 Mar 2006 Claimants' letter to the Chairman of the Administrative Council of ICSID Decision of the Chairman of the ICSID Administrative Council on the Disqualification of Prof. Lalive and Judge Bedjaoui 21 Feb 2006 Decision of the Chairman of the ICSID Administrative Council on the Disqualification of Prof. Lalive and Judge Bedjaoui (Spanis) Decision of the Chairman of the ICSID Administrative Council on the Disqualification of Prof. Lalive and Judge Bedjaoui (French) Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 19 Jan 2006 Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 2 Jan 2006 Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 7 Dec 2005 Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Procedural Order No. 3 2 Apr 2015 Procedural Order No. 3 (English) Procedural Order No. 3 (French)Source: ICSID Website Procedural Order No. 2 16 Dec 2014 Procedural Order No. 2 (English) Procedural Order No. 2 (French)Source: ICSID Website Procedural Order No. 1 18 May 2014 Procedural Order No. 1 (English) Procedural Order No. 1 (French)Source: ICSID Website Proposal for Disqualification of Two Members of the Arbitral Tribunal Sir Franklin Berman and M V. V. Veeder 22 Nov 2016 Proposal for Disqualification of Two Members of the Arbitral Tribunal Sir Franklin Berman and M V. V. Veeder (French) Proposal for Disqualification of Two Members of the Arbitral Tribunal Sir Franklin Berman and M V. V. Veeder (Spanish)Source: ICSID Website Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of Arbitrators Franklin Berman and V. V. Veeder and the Government of Chile 13 Jan 2017 Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of Arbitrators Franklin Berman and V. V. Veeder and the Government of Chile (French) Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of Arbitrators Franklin Berman and V. V. Veeder and the Government of Chile(Spanish)Source: ICSID Website Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of V. V. Veeder and on the Silence of Franklin Berman 21 Mar 2017 Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of V. V. Veeder and on the Silence of Franklin Berman (Spanish) Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of V. V. Veeder and on the Silence of Franklin Berman (French) Claimants' Letter Regarding the Abcense of Franklin Berman from Participating in the Disqualification Decision 11 Mar 2017 Claimants' Letter Regarding the Abcense of Franklin Berman from Participating in the Disqualification DecisionSource: ICSID Website Claimants' Proposal and Reasons for Disqualification of the Arbitrator Franklin Berman 4 Mar 2017 Claimants' Proposal and Reasons for Disqualification of the Arbitrator Franklin Berman (Rectification Proceeding) (French) Claimants' Request for Disqualification of Franklin Berman to Decide on the Challenge of V.V. Veeder 28 Feb 2017 Claimants' Request for Disqualification of Franklin Berman to Decide on the Challenge of V.V. Veeder (French) Letter from Franklin Berman to ICSID re New Challenge to the Arbitrator V.V. Veeder 1 Mar 2017 Letter from Franklin Berman to ICSID re New Challenge to the Arbitrator V.V. Veeder Claimants' Request for Disqualification of the Arbitrator Mr. V.V. Veeder 23 Feb 2017 Claimants' Request for Disqualification of the Arbitrator Mr. V.V. Veeder (French)Source: ICSID Website ICSID's Cover Letter re Disqualification Challenge and Resumption of Rectification Proceeding 22 Feb 2017 ICSID's Cover Letter re Disqualification Challenge and Resumption of Rectification Proceeding (English) ICSID's Cover Letter re Disqualification Challenge and Resumption of Rectification Proceeding (French) Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Sir Franklin Berman QC and Mr V.V. Veeder QC 21 Feb 2017 Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Sir Franklin Berman QC and Mr V.V. Veeder QC (French) Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Sir Franklin Berman QC and Mr V.V. Veeder QC (English) Claimants' Request for In-Camera Examination of ICSID Documents Known to Respondent's Counsel and the Arbitrator, Veeder 27 Jan 2017 Claimants' Request for In-Camera Examination of ICSID Documents Known to Respondent's Counsel and the Arbitrator, Veeder(French)Source: ICSID Website ICSID's Letter 21 Nov 2016 ICSID's Letter (French) Declaration of V.V. Veeder 31 Jan 2014 Declaration of V.V. Veeder (French) Declaration of Franklin Berman 13 Jan 2014 Declaration of Franklin Berman (English) Declaration of Franklin Berman (French) ICSID's Letter 17 Dec 2013 ICSID's Letter ICSID's Letter 20 Oct 2016 ICSID's Letter (French) Claimants' Letter to ICSID re Respondent's Relationship with Members of the Essex Court Chamber 10 Oct 2016 Claimants' Letter to ICSID re Respondent's Relationship with Members of the Essex Court Chamber (French) Claimants' Disclosure Request from Arbitrators V.V. Veeder and Franklin Berman 20 Sep 2016 Claimants' Disclosure Request from Arbitrators V.V. Veeder and Franklin Berman (French) Claimants' Request for Termination of the Interpretation Proceeding 21 Apr 2017 Claimants' Request for Termination of the Interpretation Proceeding (French) Claimants' Request for Termination of the Rectification Proceeding 21 Apr 2017 Claimants' Request for Termination of the Rectification Proceeding (French) Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Mr. V.V. Veeder and Sir Franklin Berman QC 13 Apr 2017 Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Mr. V.V. Veeder and Sir Franklin Berman QC (English) Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Mr. V.V. Veeder and Sir Franklin Berman QC (French) Claimants' Objections to the Manner of Appointment of Chile's Arbitrator 4 Apr 2017 Claimants' Objections to the Manner of Appointment of Chile's Arbitrator (French) Claimants' Observations on Chile's Explanations about the Proposal for Disqualification of Arbitrators Berman and Veeder 24 Mar 2017 Claimants' Observations on Chile's Explanations about the Proposal for Disqualification of Arbitrators Berman and Veeder(French) Claimants' Observations on Chile's Explanations about the Proposal for Disqualification of Arbitrators Berman and Veeder(Spanish Claimants' Letter to ICSID re Acknowledging the Receipt of the Order and Consent to the Publication of Case Documents 15 May 2017 Claimants' Letter to ICSID re Acknowledging the Receipt of the Order and Consent to the Publication of Case Documents (French) Cover Letter - Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding 12 May 2017 Cover Letter - Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding (English) Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding 12 May 2017 Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding (English) Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding (French) Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding (Spanish) Claimants' Letter to ICSID - re Discontinuance of the Proceeding 2 May 2017 Claimants' Letter to ICSID - re Discontinuance of the Proceeding (French) Request for a Preliminary Ruling re Disclosure of Information on Payments Made to Any Member/Lawyer of the Essex Court Chamber 29 Jun 2017 Request for a Preliminary Ruling re Disclosure of Information on Payments Made to Any Member/Lawyer of the Essex Court ChamberSource: ICSID Website Order of Santiago Civil Court ordering Chile to Produce Payments to the Essex Court Chambers 24 Jul 2017 Order of Santiago Civil Court ordering Chile to Produce Payments to the Essex Court Chambers (English) Order of Santiago Civil Court ordering Chile to Produce Payments to the Essex Court Chambers (French) Order of Santiago Civil Court ordering Chile to Produce Payments to the Essex Court Chambers (Spanish)Source: ICSID Website Tribunal's Response to Claimants' Request for the Disclosure of Information by Chile 15 Jun 2017 Tribunal's Response to Claimants' Request for the Disclosure of Information by Chile (English) Tribunal's Response to Claimants' Request for the Disclosure of Information by Chile (French)Source: ICSID Website Claimants' Request for the Disclosure of Information by Chile 19 Jun 2017 Claimants' Request for the Disclosure of Information by Chile (French)Source: ICSID Website Tribunal's Letter re Resumption after the Resignation of the Arbitrator Appointed by Chile 25 Apr 2006 Tribunal's Letter re Resumption after the Resignation of the Arbitrator Appointed by Chile (French) Tribunal's Letter re Resumption after the Resignation of the Arbitrator Appointed by Chile (Spanish)Source: ICSID Website Claimants' Request for the Annulment of the Award of 13 September 2016 10 Oct 2017 Claimants' Request for the Annulment of the Award of 13 September 2016 (French)Source: ICSID Website Decision on Rectification of the Award 6 Oct 2017 Decision on Rectification of the Award (English) Decision on Rectification of the Award (French) Decision on Rectification of the Award (Spanish)Source: ICSID Website Parlamentary question to the Foreign Affairs Minster of Chile on the VPC and FPA ICSID arbitration 20 Sep 2017 Parlamentary question to the Foreign Affairs Minster of Chile on the VPC and FPA ICSID arbitrationSource: ICSID Website President Allande Foundation's Press Release re Chile's Payment to the Essex Court Chambers 12 Oct 2017 President Allande Foundation's Press Release re Chile's Payment to the Essex Court Chambers Claimants' Request for Document Production re Payments Made by the Government of Chile to Members of Essex Court Chambers(French 21 Dec 2017 Claimants' Request for Document Production re Payments Made by the Government of Chile to Members of Essex Court Chambers(French Decision on the Request for the Stay of the Enforcement of the Award 15 Mar 2018 Decision on the Request for the Stay of the Enforcement of the Award (English) Decision on the Request for the Stay of the Enforcement of the Award (French)Source: ICSID Website Claimant's' Memorial Concerning the Annulment of the Award of 13 September 2016 27 Apr 2018 Claimant's' Memorial Concerning the Annulment of the Award of 13 September 2016 (English) Claimant's' Memorial Concerning the Annulment of the Award of 13 September 2016 (French) Claimants' Submission on the Conflict of Interest between Arbitrators Berman and Veeder and Chile 27 Apr 2018 Claimants' Submission on the Conflict of Interest between Arbitrators Berman and Veeder and Chile (2nd Annulment Proceeding) Claimants' Rejoinder to the Respondent's Counter-Memorial 9 Nov 2018 Claimants' Rejoinder to the Respondent's Counter-Memorial (Second Annulment Proceeding) (English Translation) Claimants' Rejoinder to the Respondent's Counter-Memorial (Second Annulment Proceeding) (French) Decision on the Request for Clarification regarding the Decision on the Stay of Enforcement of the Award 15 Jul 2019 Decision on the Request for Clarification regarding the Decision on the Stay of Enforcement of the Award (English) Decision on the Request for Clarification regarding the Decision on the Stay of Enforcement of the Award (French)Source: ICSID Website Claimants' Observations on Chile's Request for Clarification of the Decision of 15 March 2018 8 Jul 2019 Claimants' Observations on Chile's Request for Clarification of the Decision of 15 March 2018 (French)Source: ICSID Website Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings 14 Mar 2019 Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings (French)Source: IA Reporter Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings 13 Mar 2019 Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings (French)Source: IA Reporter Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings 12 Mar 2019 Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings (French)Source: IA Reporter Concurring Opinion of Nicolas Angelet 7 Jan 2020 Concurring Opinion of Nicolas Angelet (English) Concurring Opinion of Nicolas Angelet (French) Decision on Annulment 8 Jan 2020 Decision on Annulment (English) Decision on Annulment (French) Order of Madrid Court of First Instance 8 Mar 2022 Order of Madrid Court of First InstanceSource: Investor-State LawGuide Order of Madrid Court of First Instance 7 Dec 2021 Order of Madrid Court of First InstanceSource: ICSID Website Application for Enforcement 29 Oct 2021 Application for EnforcementSource: IAReporter Letter from the Technical General Secretary of the Spanish Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Jurisdictional Immunities of Chile 17 Oct 2023 Letter from the Technical General Secretary of the Spanish Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Jurisdictional Immunities of Chile Claimants' Response to Chile's Plea to Decline Jurisdiction 7 Jun 2024 Claimants' Response to Chile's Plea to Decline Jurisdiction (Enforcement Proceedings Before the Madrid Court of First Instance) Spanish Law on Civil Procedure Articles 712-716 Opinion on Sovereign Immunities of Chile and Jurisdiction of the Enforcement Court 14 Dec 2022 Opinion on Sovereign Immunities of Chile and Jurisdiction of the Enforcement Court (Enforcement Proceedings in Madrid) Claimants' Submission to the Madrid Court Regarding Judgment of the Chilean Supreme Court 2 Sep 2024 Claimants' Submission to the Madrid Court Regarding Judgment of the Chilean Supreme Court (Spanish) Judgment of the Chilean Supreme Court 16 Aug 2024 Judgment of the Chilean Supreme Court (Spanish) Section: ICSID Awards
Annex 1: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General 6 Apr 1999 Annex 1: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General
Annex 2: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General 8 Apr 1999 Annex 2: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General
Annex 4: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General 19 Apr 1999 Annex 4: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General
Decision on Provisional Measures 25 Sep 2001 Decision on Provisional Measures (Spanish) Decision on Provisional Measures (French)
Opinion of Prof. Guillermo Bruna 27 Jun 2002 Opinion of Prof. Guillermo Bruna (French) Opinion of Prof. Guillermo Bruna (Spanish)
Opinion of Alejandro Arraez and Associates 3 Sep 2002 Opinion of Alejandro Arraez and Associates (French) Opinion of Alejandro Arraez and Associates (Spanish)
Opinion of Professor Fernando Mariño 19 Feb 2003 Opinion of Professor Fernando Mariño (French) Opinion of Professor Fernando Mariño (Spanish)
Procedural Order No. 13 24 Oct 2006 Procedural Order No. 13 (French) Procedural Order No. 13 (Spanish)
Procedural Order No. 14 22 Nov 2006 Procedural Order No. 14 (French) Procedural Order No. 14 (Spanish)
Annex 1: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award 23 Mar 2007 Annex 1: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (French)
Accompanying Document to: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award 23 Mar 2007 Accompanying Document to: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (French)
Decision on Arbitration Expenses 14 Mar 2008 Decision on Arbitration Expenses (French) Decision on Arbitration Expenses (Spanish)
Annex 2: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award 26 May 2008 Annex 2: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (Spanish)
Accompanying Document II to: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award 26 May 2008 Accompanying Document II to: Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (French)
Application for Revision 2 Jun 2008 Application for Revision (French) Application for Revision (Spanish)
Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award 1 Aug 2008 Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (French) Claimant's Observations to Chile's Petition to Stay Enforcement of the Award (Spanish)
Decision on Stay of Enforcement of the Award 5 Aug 2008 Decision on Stay of Enforcement of the Award (French) Decision on Stay of Enforcement of the Award (Spanish)
Annex 3: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General 10 Sep 2008 Annex 3: Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General
Claimants' Reply, Application for Revision 3 Nov 2008 Claimants' Reply, Application for Revision (French) Claimants' Reply, Application for Revision (Spanish)
Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General 10 Jul 2009 Claimant's Letter to the Secretary General (French)
Minutes of the First Session of the ad hoc Committee 29 Jan 2010 Minutes of the First Session of the ad hoc Committee (French)
Decision on Admissibility of the Application for Annulment 4 May 2010 Decision on Admissibility of the Application for Annulment (French)
Decision on the Republic of Chile's Application for a Stay of Enforcement of the Award 5 May 2010 Decision on the Republic of Chile's Application for a Stay of Enforcement of the Award
Claimants' Response to the Application for Annulment of the Award 15 Oct 2010 Claimants' Response to the Application for Annulment of the Award (French) Claimants' Response to the Application for Annulment of the Award (Spanish)
Rejoinder to Response to Chile's Annulment Application 28 Feb 2011 Rejoinder to Response to Chile's Annulment Application (French) Rejoinder to Response to Chile's Annulment Application (Spanish)
Decision on the Application for Annulment of the Republic of Chile 18 Dec 2012 Decision on the Application for Annulment of the Republic of Chile (French) Decision on the Application for Annulment of the Republic of Chile (English)
Decree of Spanish Court of First Instance 6 Mar 2013 Decree of Spanish Court of First Instance (Spanish)
Resolution of Spanish Court of First Instance 6 Mar 2013 Resolution of Spanish Court of First Instance (Spanish)
Response to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision 29 Mar 2013 Response to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision (French)
Response to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision 29 Mar 2013 Response to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision (Spanish)
Response to Chile's Request for Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award of 8 May 2008 8 Apr 2013 Response to Chile's Request for Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award of 8 May 2008 (French)
Reply to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision 26 Apr 2013 Reply to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision (Spanish) Reply to Chile's Request for a Supplementary Decision (French)
Decision on Chile's Request for a Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award 16 May 2013 Decision on Chile's Request for a Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award (English) Decision on Chile's Request for a Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award (Spanish) Decision on Chile's Request for a Stay of Enforcement of the Unannulled Portion of the Award (French)
Requête en vue de déterminer le montant de la réparation pour violation de l'API Espagne-Chili 18 Jun 2013 Requête en vue de déterminer le montant de la réparation pour violation de l'API Espagne-Chili (French)
Decision of Spanish Court on Execution of Award 4 Jul 2013 Decision of Spanish Court on Execution of Award (Spanish)
Annex 2 to Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal 10 Jul 2013 Annex 2 to Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal (French)
Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal 10 Jul 2013 Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal (French)
Annex 1 to Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal 10 Jul 2013 Annex 1 to Claimant's Letter to ICSID Regarding Constitution of New Tribunal (French)
Decision on the Republic of Chile's Request for Supplementation of the Annulment Decision 11 Sep 2013 Decision on the Republic of Chile's Request for Supplementation of the Annulment Decision (English) Decision on the Republic of Chile's Request for Supplementation of the Annulment Decision (French) Decision on the Republic of Chile's Request for Supplementation of the Annulment Decision (Spanish)
Letter of Philippe Sands to ICSID on his appointment to the Tribunal 11 Sep 2013 Letter of Philippe Sands to ICSID on his appointment to the Tribunal
Claimant's Submissions on Constitution of Arbitral Tribunal 26 Dec 2013 Claimant's Submissions on Constitution of Arbitral Tribunal (French)
Philippe Sands' Letter of Resignation from the Tribunal 10 Jan 2014 Philippe Sands' Letter of Resignation from the Tribunal
Comments on the Proposed Disqualification of Philippe Sands 23 Jan 2014 Comments on the Proposed Disqualification of Philippe Sands (French)
Claimants’ Memorial on Quantum 27 Jun 2014 Claimants’ Memorial on Quantum (French) Claimants’ Memorial on Quantum (Spanish)
Overview of Chile’s Tactics that Have Frustrated the Arbitration 27 Jun 2014 Overview of Chile’s Tactics that Have Frustrated the Arbitration (French)
Request for Correction of Material Errors in the Award of 13 September 2016 27 Oct 2016 Request for Correction of Material Errors in the Award of 13 September 2016 (French)
Claimants’ Request to Chile for Full Disclosure of Its Relationship with Members of the Essex Court Chamber 13 Oct 2016 Claimants’ Request to Chile for Full Disclosure of Its Relationship with Members of the Essex Court Chamber (French)Source: IA Reporter
Claimants' Request for the Interpretation of the Award of 8 May 2008 7 Oct 2016 Claimants' Request for the Interpretation of the Award of 8 May 2008 (French)
Request for the Annulment of the Award dated 8 May 2008 5 Sep 2008 Request for the Annulment of the Award dated 8 May 2008Source: ICSID Website
Request for Disqualification of Professor Philippe Sands as Arbitrator in the Resubmission Proceeding 18 Dec 2013 Request for Disqualification of Professor Philippe Sands as Arbitrator in the Resubmission ProceedingSource: ICSID Website
Recommendation of the PCA Secretary-General as to the Proposal for the Disqualification of Prof. Lalive and Judge bedjaoui 17 Feb 2006 Recommendation of the PCA Secretary-General as to the Proposal for the Disqualification of Prof. Lalive and Judge bedjaouiSource: ICSID Website
Hearings of 13, 14, 15 and 16 April 2015 16 Apr 2015 Hearings of 13, 14, 15 and 16 April 2015Source: ICSID Website
Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 5 Dec 2005 Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French)Source: ICSID Website
The Secretary General of ICSID reveals the contents of the ex parte meeting of 02-09-2005 with the High Delegation of Chile 2 Dec 2005 The Secretary General of ICSID reveals the contents of the ex parte meeting of 02-09-2005 with the High Delegation of ChileSource: ICSID Website
Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 28 Nov 2005 Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French)
Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 17 Nov 2005 Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French)
Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 7 Oct 2005 Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French)
Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 4 Oct 2005 Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French)
Ex parte Meeting of a High Delegation of Chile with the Secretary General of ICSID 8 Sep 2005 Ex parte Meeting of a High Delegation of Chile with the Secretary General of ICSID (French) Ex parte Meeting of a High Delegation of Chile with the Secretary General of ICSID (Spanish)
Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 2 Sep 2005 Prof. Pierre Lalive's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French)
Respondent's Request for the Disqualification of the Three Members of the Tribunal 24 Aug 2005 Respondent's Request for the Disqualification of the Three Members of the Tribunal (Spanish)
Claimants Ask the General Secretary of ICSID to Appoint a Qualified New Arbitrator 11 May 2006 Claimants Ask the General Secretary of ICSID to Appoint a Qualified New Arbitrator
Response of the Secretary General of ICSID 7 Mar 2006 Response of the Secretary General of ICSID (French)
Claimants' letter to the Chairman of the Administrative Council of ICSID 2 Mar 2006 Claimants' letter to the Chairman of the Administrative Council of ICSID
Decision of the Chairman of the ICSID Administrative Council on the Disqualification of Prof. Lalive and Judge Bedjaoui 21 Feb 2006 Decision of the Chairman of the ICSID Administrative Council on the Disqualification of Prof. Lalive and Judge Bedjaoui (Spanis) Decision of the Chairman of the ICSID Administrative Council on the Disqualification of Prof. Lalive and Judge Bedjaoui (French)
Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 19 Jan 2006 Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French)
Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 2 Jan 2006 Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French)
Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID 7 Dec 2005 Judge M. Bedjaoui's Letter to the Secretary General of ICSID (French)
Procedural Order No. 3 2 Apr 2015 Procedural Order No. 3 (English) Procedural Order No. 3 (French)Source: ICSID Website
Procedural Order No. 2 16 Dec 2014 Procedural Order No. 2 (English) Procedural Order No. 2 (French)Source: ICSID Website
Procedural Order No. 1 18 May 2014 Procedural Order No. 1 (English) Procedural Order No. 1 (French)Source: ICSID Website
Proposal for Disqualification of Two Members of the Arbitral Tribunal Sir Franklin Berman and M V. V. Veeder 22 Nov 2016 Proposal for Disqualification of Two Members of the Arbitral Tribunal Sir Franklin Berman and M V. V. Veeder (French) Proposal for Disqualification of Two Members of the Arbitral Tribunal Sir Franklin Berman and M V. V. Veeder (Spanish)Source: ICSID Website
Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of Arbitrators Franklin Berman and V. V. Veeder and the Government of Chile 13 Jan 2017 Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of Arbitrators Franklin Berman and V. V. Veeder and the Government of Chile (French) Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of Arbitrators Franklin Berman and V. V. Veeder and the Government of Chile(Spanish)Source: ICSID Website
Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of V. V. Veeder and on the Silence of Franklin Berman 21 Mar 2017 Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of V. V. Veeder and on the Silence of Franklin Berman (Spanish) Claimants' Observations on the Explanations of V. V. Veeder and on the Silence of Franklin Berman (French)
Claimants' Letter Regarding the Abcense of Franklin Berman from Participating in the Disqualification Decision 11 Mar 2017 Claimants' Letter Regarding the Abcense of Franklin Berman from Participating in the Disqualification DecisionSource: ICSID Website
Claimants' Proposal and Reasons for Disqualification of the Arbitrator Franklin Berman 4 Mar 2017 Claimants' Proposal and Reasons for Disqualification of the Arbitrator Franklin Berman (Rectification Proceeding) (French)
Claimants' Request for Disqualification of Franklin Berman to Decide on the Challenge of V.V. Veeder 28 Feb 2017 Claimants' Request for Disqualification of Franklin Berman to Decide on the Challenge of V.V. Veeder (French)
Letter from Franklin Berman to ICSID re New Challenge to the Arbitrator V.V. Veeder 1 Mar 2017 Letter from Franklin Berman to ICSID re New Challenge to the Arbitrator V.V. Veeder
Claimants' Request for Disqualification of the Arbitrator Mr. V.V. Veeder 23 Feb 2017 Claimants' Request for Disqualification of the Arbitrator Mr. V.V. Veeder (French)Source: ICSID Website
ICSID's Cover Letter re Disqualification Challenge and Resumption of Rectification Proceeding 22 Feb 2017 ICSID's Cover Letter re Disqualification Challenge and Resumption of Rectification Proceeding (English) ICSID's Cover Letter re Disqualification Challenge and Resumption of Rectification Proceeding (French)
Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Sir Franklin Berman QC and Mr V.V. Veeder QC 21 Feb 2017 Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Sir Franklin Berman QC and Mr V.V. Veeder QC (French) Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Sir Franklin Berman QC and Mr V.V. Veeder QC (English)
Claimants' Request for In-Camera Examination of ICSID Documents Known to Respondent's Counsel and the Arbitrator, Veeder 27 Jan 2017 Claimants' Request for In-Camera Examination of ICSID Documents Known to Respondent's Counsel and the Arbitrator, Veeder(French)Source: ICSID Website
Declaration of Franklin Berman 13 Jan 2014 Declaration of Franklin Berman (English) Declaration of Franklin Berman (French)
Claimants' Letter to ICSID re Respondent's Relationship with Members of the Essex Court Chamber 10 Oct 2016 Claimants' Letter to ICSID re Respondent's Relationship with Members of the Essex Court Chamber (French)
Claimants' Disclosure Request from Arbitrators V.V. Veeder and Franklin Berman 20 Sep 2016 Claimants' Disclosure Request from Arbitrators V.V. Veeder and Franklin Berman (French)
Claimants' Request for Termination of the Interpretation Proceeding 21 Apr 2017 Claimants' Request for Termination of the Interpretation Proceeding (French)
Claimants' Request for Termination of the Rectification Proceeding 21 Apr 2017 Claimants' Request for Termination of the Rectification Proceeding (French)
Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Mr. V.V. Veeder and Sir Franklin Berman QC 13 Apr 2017 Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Mr. V.V. Veeder and Sir Franklin Berman QC (English) Decision on the Proposal to Disqualify Mr. V.V. Veeder and Sir Franklin Berman QC (French)
Claimants' Objections to the Manner of Appointment of Chile's Arbitrator 4 Apr 2017 Claimants' Objections to the Manner of Appointment of Chile's Arbitrator (French)
Claimants' Observations on Chile's Explanations about the Proposal for Disqualification of Arbitrators Berman and Veeder 24 Mar 2017 Claimants' Observations on Chile's Explanations about the Proposal for Disqualification of Arbitrators Berman and Veeder(French) Claimants' Observations on Chile's Explanations about the Proposal for Disqualification of Arbitrators Berman and Veeder(Spanish
Claimants' Letter to ICSID re Acknowledging the Receipt of the Order and Consent to the Publication of Case Documents 15 May 2017 Claimants' Letter to ICSID re Acknowledging the Receipt of the Order and Consent to the Publication of Case Documents (French)
Cover Letter - Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding 12 May 2017 Cover Letter - Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding (English)
Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding 12 May 2017 Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding (English) Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding (French) Order of the Secretary-General Taking Note of the Discontinuance of the Proceeding (Spanish)
Claimants' Letter to ICSID - re Discontinuance of the Proceeding 2 May 2017 Claimants' Letter to ICSID - re Discontinuance of the Proceeding (French)
Request for a Preliminary Ruling re Disclosure of Information on Payments Made to Any Member/Lawyer of the Essex Court Chamber 29 Jun 2017 Request for a Preliminary Ruling re Disclosure of Information on Payments Made to Any Member/Lawyer of the Essex Court ChamberSource: ICSID Website
Order of Santiago Civil Court ordering Chile to Produce Payments to the Essex Court Chambers 24 Jul 2017 Order of Santiago Civil Court ordering Chile to Produce Payments to the Essex Court Chambers (English) Order of Santiago Civil Court ordering Chile to Produce Payments to the Essex Court Chambers (French) Order of Santiago Civil Court ordering Chile to Produce Payments to the Essex Court Chambers (Spanish)Source: ICSID Website
Tribunal's Response to Claimants' Request for the Disclosure of Information by Chile 15 Jun 2017 Tribunal's Response to Claimants' Request for the Disclosure of Information by Chile (English) Tribunal's Response to Claimants' Request for the Disclosure of Information by Chile (French)Source: ICSID Website
Claimants' Request for the Disclosure of Information by Chile 19 Jun 2017 Claimants' Request for the Disclosure of Information by Chile (French)Source: ICSID Website
Tribunal's Letter re Resumption after the Resignation of the Arbitrator Appointed by Chile 25 Apr 2006 Tribunal's Letter re Resumption after the Resignation of the Arbitrator Appointed by Chile (French) Tribunal's Letter re Resumption after the Resignation of the Arbitrator Appointed by Chile (Spanish)Source: ICSID Website
Claimants' Request for the Annulment of the Award of 13 September 2016 10 Oct 2017 Claimants' Request for the Annulment of the Award of 13 September 2016 (French)Source: ICSID Website
Decision on Rectification of the Award 6 Oct 2017 Decision on Rectification of the Award (English) Decision on Rectification of the Award (French) Decision on Rectification of the Award (Spanish)Source: ICSID Website
Parlamentary question to the Foreign Affairs Minster of Chile on the VPC and FPA ICSID arbitration 20 Sep 2017 Parlamentary question to the Foreign Affairs Minster of Chile on the VPC and FPA ICSID arbitrationSource: ICSID Website
President Allande Foundation's Press Release re Chile's Payment to the Essex Court Chambers 12 Oct 2017 President Allande Foundation's Press Release re Chile's Payment to the Essex Court Chambers
Claimants' Request for Document Production re Payments Made by the Government of Chile to Members of Essex Court Chambers(French 21 Dec 2017 Claimants' Request for Document Production re Payments Made by the Government of Chile to Members of Essex Court Chambers(French
Decision on the Request for the Stay of the Enforcement of the Award 15 Mar 2018 Decision on the Request for the Stay of the Enforcement of the Award (English) Decision on the Request for the Stay of the Enforcement of the Award (French)Source: ICSID Website
Claimant's' Memorial Concerning the Annulment of the Award of 13 September 2016 27 Apr 2018 Claimant's' Memorial Concerning the Annulment of the Award of 13 September 2016 (English) Claimant's' Memorial Concerning the Annulment of the Award of 13 September 2016 (French)
Claimants' Submission on the Conflict of Interest between Arbitrators Berman and Veeder and Chile 27 Apr 2018 Claimants' Submission on the Conflict of Interest between Arbitrators Berman and Veeder and Chile (2nd Annulment Proceeding)
Claimants' Rejoinder to the Respondent's Counter-Memorial 9 Nov 2018 Claimants' Rejoinder to the Respondent's Counter-Memorial (Second Annulment Proceeding) (English Translation) Claimants' Rejoinder to the Respondent's Counter-Memorial (Second Annulment Proceeding) (French)
Decision on the Request for Clarification regarding the Decision on the Stay of Enforcement of the Award 15 Jul 2019 Decision on the Request for Clarification regarding the Decision on the Stay of Enforcement of the Award (English) Decision on the Request for Clarification regarding the Decision on the Stay of Enforcement of the Award (French)Source: ICSID Website
Claimants' Observations on Chile's Request for Clarification of the Decision of 15 March 2018 8 Jul 2019 Claimants' Observations on Chile's Request for Clarification of the Decision of 15 March 2018 (French)Source: ICSID Website
Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings 14 Mar 2019 Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings (French)Source: IA Reporter
Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings 13 Mar 2019 Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings (French)Source: IA Reporter
Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings 12 Mar 2019 Transcripts of Hearing - Second Annulment Proceedings (French)Source: IA Reporter
Concurring Opinion of Nicolas Angelet 7 Jan 2020 Concurring Opinion of Nicolas Angelet (English) Concurring Opinion of Nicolas Angelet (French)
Order of Madrid Court of First Instance 8 Mar 2022 Order of Madrid Court of First InstanceSource: Investor-State LawGuide
Order of Madrid Court of First Instance 7 Dec 2021 Order of Madrid Court of First InstanceSource: ICSID Website
Letter from the Technical General Secretary of the Spanish Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Jurisdictional Immunities of Chile 17 Oct 2023 Letter from the Technical General Secretary of the Spanish Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Jurisdictional Immunities of Chile
Claimants' Response to Chile's Plea to Decline Jurisdiction 7 Jun 2024 Claimants' Response to Chile's Plea to Decline Jurisdiction (Enforcement Proceedings Before the Madrid Court of First Instance) Spanish Law on Civil Procedure Articles 712-716
Opinion on Sovereign Immunities of Chile and Jurisdiction of the Enforcement Court 14 Dec 2022 Opinion on Sovereign Immunities of Chile and Jurisdiction of the Enforcement Court (Enforcement Proceedings in Madrid)
Claimants' Submission to the Madrid Court Regarding Judgment of the Chilean Supreme Court 2 Sep 2024 Claimants' Submission to the Madrid Court Regarding Judgment of the Chilean Supreme Court (Spanish)
