Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Mohamed Abdel Raouf Bahgat v. Egypt

Case summary

At a glance

Parties
Mohamed Abdel Raouf Bahgat (Finland) v. the Arab Republic of Egypt
Case no.
PCA Case No. 2012-07
Forum and rules
UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules 1976; PCA as registry; seat The Hague
Treaty
Finland–Egypt BITs of 5 May 1980 and 3 March 2004; Egyptian Investment Law (Law No. 8 of 1997)
Tribunal
Prof. Rüdiger Wolfrum (Presiding), Prof. W. Michael Reisman, Prof. Francisco Orrego Vicuña (died 2 October 2018), replaced by Mr Laurent Lévy
Sector
Iron ore mining and steel production (Aswan)
Outcome
Jurisdiction upheld (30 November 2017). Final Award (23 December 2019): Egypt liable for expropriation and unfair treatment; the claimant recovered his lost investment plus FET compensation; moral damages refused.
Amount
Claimed: at least USD 103.5 million plus USD 5 million moral damages. Awarded: USD 43.77 million plus interest at 12-month USD LIBOR + 2%, compounded annually from 19 February 2000. Costs: EUR 650,584.85, GBP 6,160,320.48 and USD 900,000 (90% of the reasonable costs fixed by the Tribunal).

The dispute

Mr Bahgat, born in Egypt and naturalised in Finland in 1971, founded ADEMCO and AISCO to mine iron ore near Aswan and build a steel plant. ADEMCO's 30-year mining concession was confirmed by Law No. 166 of 14 June 1998. On 5 February 2000 the police arrested him. His assets and the companies' assets were frozen, and the authorities took over the Project site. He was held until March 2003 and was later subject to a travel ban. He claimed expropriation, breach of fair and equitable treatment and of full protection and security under the 1980 and 2004 Finland–Egypt BITs, and breaches of the Egyptian Investment Law. Egypt objected that he was an Egyptian national who had lost his Finnish nationality in 1997, and that the claims fell outside the temporal scope of both treaties. On the merits it argued that the Project was doomed by poor ore quality, and it denied causation and damage.

Key holdings

  1. Jurisdiction ratione personae upheld. The Tribunal deferred to the Finnish Supreme Administrative Court's judgment of 15 November 2016 that the claimant had been a Finnish national since 1971. Neither BIT nor the UNCITRAL Rules bars claims by dual nationals, so proof of Finnish nationality is enough. Decision on Jurisdiction ¶¶ 216, 222–227
  2. Jurisdiction ratione temporis upheld under Article 9(2) of the 2004 BIT. The dispute in its legal sense arose only when it was first raised in writing on 8 July 2011. It is not a continuation of the Egyptian criminal proceedings. The 1980 BIT's substantive standards apply to acts before 5 February 2005, through its survival clause (Article 9(3)); the 2004 BIT applies to later acts. The Tribunal also has jurisdiction over claims under the Egyptian Investment Law. Decision on Jurisdiction ¶¶ 300–303, 313–318
  3. Egypt breached Articles 2(1) and 3(1) of the 1980 BIT and Article 2(2) of the 2004 BIT. The other treaty claims and the claims under the Egyptian Investment Law were dismissed. Final Award ¶ 618(B)–(F)
  4. The Project was technically and economically viable on 19 February 2000, and Egypt's measures caused its end. By majority, the Tribunal valued the loss by the lost-investment method at USD 39.77 million. This includes USD 30 million paid to Mannesmann Demag, which the Tribunal accepted came from the claimant's own funds. It rejected Egypt's comparable-transactions valuation and its unsubstantiated suggestion of money laundering. Final Award ¶¶ 466–494, 500–501
  5. Separate compensation for unfair treatment: USD 3 million for the conduct of the prosecution and of the lower courts (Article 2(1), 1980 BIT), and USD 1 million for keeping the travel ban after acquittal and the delayed or continuing asset freezes (Article 2(2), 2004 BIT). Moral damages were refused: the Tribunal was not convinced it had power to award them under the treaties, although it found the treatment of the claimant disproportionately harsh and degrading. Final Award ¶¶ 502–503, 519–521
  6. Interest is due at LIBOR + 2%, compounded annually, from 19 February 2000, including the periods of delay. Egyptian rules against compound interest do not apply to treaty claims. Final Award ¶¶ 534–542
  7. Costs: the claimant bears 10% of the arbitration costs of EUR 1,160,000. Egypt pays 90% of his reasonable legal costs, which include counsel's success fees. The claimant bears his third-party funding costs (Buttonwood, Vannin) himself. Final Award ¶¶ 588–592, 613–614

Procedural history

  1. 3 November 2011Notice of Arbitration under Article 9(2)(d) of the 2004 BIT and, in the alternative, Article 7 of the 1980 BIT.
  2. 2 April 2012The party-appointed arbitrators appoint Prof. Wolfrum as Presiding Arbitrator. The Terms of Appointment, with the PCA as registry, are signed on 27 June 2012.
  3. 25 September 2013Procedural Order No. 3 suspends the proceedings while the claimant challenges, in the Finnish courts, the Finnish Immigration Service's decision of 23 April 2013 that he had lost his Finnish nationality.
  4. 15 November 2016The Finnish Supreme Administrative Court revokes the earlier Finnish decisions and confirms his Finnish nationality; the arbitration resumes.
  5. 30 November 2017Decision on Jurisdiction: Egypt's objections are dismissed. Prof. Orrego Vicuña appends a separate opinion.
  6. 30 October 2018Mr Laurent Lévy is appointed after Prof. Orrego Vicuña's death on 2 October 2018. The merits hearings are held in The Hague on 12–14 December 2018 and 24–27 April 2019.
  7. 23 December 2019Final Award: USD 43.77 million plus compound interest, and costs.
  8. 3 July 2020Hague District Court (summary proceedings, published 8 July 2020) refuses to lift the Minister's instruction to release the claimant's attachment of an Egyptian-owned house in The Hague, holding that it is immune from execution. Egypt had also sued in the Dutch courts to annul the award; the published documents do not show the outcome.
  9. 4 April 2023English High Court refuses summary judgment to the claimant's former solicitors (Crane Legal, formerly Balsara, and Saunders Law). They had sued Mr Bahgat's estate for fees under conditional fee agreements. The judgment records that Mr Bahgat died on 8 October 2022 and that his dispute with Egypt was said to have been settled for USD 99.5 million.

Tribunal, counsel and experts

Decided by
  • Rüdiger Wolfrum President — chosen by the co-arbitrators
  • W. Michael Reisman Co-arbitrator — appointed by the claimant
  • Francisco Orrego Vicuña Co-arbitrator — appointed by the respondent (appended a separate opinion to the Decision on Jurisdiction; died 2 October 2018)
  • Laurent Lévy Co-arbitrator — appointed by the respondent (replaced Prof. Orrego Vicuña on 30 October 2018)
  • H.J. Vetter Judge, Rechtbank Den Haag — appointed by a court
  • Philip Kramer Judge, High Court of Justice of England and Wales — appointed by a court
Experts
Kadri Dagdelen (claimant) · Erik Spiller (claimant) · Joseph J. Poveromo (claimant) · Noel Matthews (claimant) · William Inglis (claimant) · Mohamed Talaat (claimant) · Aulis Aarnio (claimant) · Tuomas Ojanen (claimant) · Mike Armitage (respondent) · Nick Fox (respondent) · John Willis (respondent) · Jürgen Cappel (respondent) · Gervase MacGregor (respondent)

Run a conflict check on these names →

Keywords

Summary generated with AI from the published documents — refer to the award for the authoritative text.