Hulley Enterprises Limited (Cyprus) v. The Russian Federation
Tribunal, counsel and experts
- Decided by
- L. Yves Fortier President — appointed by the institution award
- Charles Poncet Co-arbitrator — appointed by the claimant award
- Stephen M. Schwebel Co-arbitrator — appointed by the respondent award
- For the claimant
- Shearman & Sterling LLP
- For the respondent
- Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP · Baker Botts LLP
- Experts
- Rudolf Dolzer (respondent) · George A. Bermann (respondent)
Run a conflict check on these names →
Read with AI from the published documents; each name links to the person’s record. A full case summary follows when it is written.
Case ID
UNCITRAL, PCA Case No. AA 226
Country
Claimant
Hulley Enterprises Limited (Cyprus)
Respondent
Russian Federation
Documents
Interim Award on Jurisdiction and Admissibility
30 November 2009
Final Award
18 July 2014
Final Award
(3.18 MB)
Expert Report of Anton V. Asoskov
30 October 2014
Expert Report of Anton V. Asoskov (English)
(205.17 KB)
Expert Report of Anton V. Asoskov (Russian)
(431.1 KB)
Expert Report of James Dow
8 November 2014
Expert Report of James Dow (English)
(1.35 MB)
Expert Report of James Dow (Russian)
(727.18 KB)
Declaration of Arkady Vitalyevich Zakharov
20 October 2015
Declaration of Gitas Povilo Anilionis
20 October 2015
Declaration of Gitas Povilo Anilionis
(5.32 MB)
Expert Opinion of Professor Rudolf Dolzer
20 October 2015
Expert Opinion of Professor George A. Berman
20 October 2015
Expert Opinion of Professor George A. Berman
20 October 2015
Expert Report of S.P. Kothari
20 October 2015
Expert Report of S.P. Kothari
(660.58 KB)
Respondent Motion to Dismiss Petition to Confirm Award filed with U.S. District Court of District of Columbia
Respondent Motion to Deny Confirmation of Award filed with U.S. District Court of District of Columbia
20 October 2015
Judgment of Hague District Court
Respondent Presentation for Hague District Court
9 February 2016
Letter by Roscosmos Regarding the Violation of the French-Russian BIT
21 October 2016
Memorandum Opinion of the US District Court for the District of Columbia
30 September 2016
Decision of the Paris Court of First Instance on Sovereign Immunity of Russia
28 April 2016
Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights on Just Satisfaction
31 July 2014
Decision of the European Court of Human Rights as to the Admissibility of the Application
29 January 2009
Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights on the Merits
17 January 2012
Decision of the Paris Court of Appeal
23 November 2016
Russia's Reply to Claimants' Response to the Notice of Supplemental Authorities
12 February 2016
Memorandum Opinion of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia II
18 August 2017
Memorandum Opinion and Order of the US District Court for the District of Columbia
9 December 2017
Source
Russia's Defense on Appeal before the Court of Appeal in The Hague
28 November 2017
Judgment of the Hague Court of Appeal
25 September 2018
Judgment of the Hague Court of Appeal
Decision of Supreme Court of the Netherlands
25 September 2020
Source
Order of US District Court for the District of Columbia
20 November 2020
Source
Memorandum Opinion of US District Court for the District of Columbia IV
20 November 2020
Source
Dutch Supreme Court’s Advocate General Opinion
23 April 2021
Source
Seventh Declaration of Professor Albert Jan Van Den Berg
10 December 2021
Source
Second Witness Statement of Tobias Cohen Jehoram
17 December 2021
Source
Memorandum Opinion of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia
13 April 2022
Source
Order of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia
13 April 2022
Source
Judgment of the Supreme Court of the Netherlands
5 November 2021
Source
Judgment of the High Court of Justice of England and Wales
26 October 2022
Source
Opinion of the Procurator General at Netherlands Supreme Court
22 September 2023
Source
Respondent Notice of Supplemental Authorities before US District Court for the District of Columbia
9 August 2023
Source
Judgement of the High Court of England and Wales
Judgement of the Supreme Court of the Netherlands 2
22 March 2024
Source
Appelees Motion to Expedite Consideration of the Appeal
19 January 2024
Source
Judgment of the UK High Court of Justice
2 October 2023
Judgment of the UK High Court of Justice
(189.69 KB)
Judgment of the UK Court of Appeal
12 February 2025
Judgment of the UK Court of Appeal
(321.15 KB)
Opinion of US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit
5 August 2025
Judgment of the Singapore International Commercial Court
25 November 2025
Section